Granite VS Marble Countertops in Your Kitchen – Which is Best?

Granite Versus Marble For Your
Lancaster, PA Kitchen

Both Are Popular Options –
Which Will You Choose
For Your Kitchen?

When you decide a kitchen remodel is the way to go for your Lancaster, PA home, your countertop material is one of your most important choices. While there are several different materials for countertops, granite and marble are often the two most widely selected.

Two of the most popular choices for kitchen countertops are granite and marble. But before you decide based on looks, you must understand the similarities and differences between the two materials.

Read on to learn the pros and cons of granite and marble so you can make an informed decision for your Lancaster, PA, kitchen countertops!

All About Granite Countertops

Granite countertops are gorgeous and are the top pick for many Lancaster, PA homeowners. However, before you decide – be sure you understand all that goes into granite.

Overall Pros Of Granite

Granite has some definite benefits for kitchens, including:

  • Less expensive when compared to marble
  • Super durable
  • Numerous colors and styles to choose from for a look you want
  • Heat resistant
  • It does not emit radon gas
  • Considered low maintenance

Overall Cons Of Granite

While there are benefits, there are cons to granite countertops as well. These drawbacks include:

  • Stains easily
  • Etching can occur when the surface is not protected
  • There can be some minor variations in style, which can bother some people if these discrepancies are seen once installed
  • Granite can break if something heavy were to drop on it
  • In terms of resale value, granite does not seem to make much of a difference in a home

Cost Of Granite

The cost of granite will depend upon the area in which you live. However, the national average price for granite countertops ranges from $40 to $80 per square foot.

The Durability Of Granite

What is interesting about granite is the fact that the durability level depends upon the color. Dark-colored granite is considered nonporous and impervious to staining. Light-colored granite is dolomite which is easier to stain and scratch compared to dark colors.

Maintenance For Granite

Granite will require maintenance from time to time. Once installed, granite countertops are sealed, which does cut down on stains, and allows water to bead on this stone. In most situations, granite is sealed yearly to ensure it maintains its beauty.

You will need to use a PH-neutral cleaner for daily cleaning to avoid damaging the sealant.

All About Marble Countertops

Marble countertops have their own beauty and are perfect for any Lancaster, PA, kitchen.

Overall Pros Of Marble

There are several benefits to using marble as your countertops in your kitchen. These benefits include:

  • Heat resistant
  • The patterns in marble – often referred to as veins – are very soft and create a look of elegance
  • It does not emit radon gas
  • Smooth to the touch
  • Several colors to choose from to match your kitchen remodel

Overall Cons Of Marble

As with everything, there are always drawbacks. For marble countertops, these drawbacks include:

  • Expensive when compared to other countertop materials
  • High maintenance
  • A lower level of durability than other materials
  • Each marble piece will have variations in style, but this is a natural part of the appearance
  • Staining and etching can happen quickly with marble countertops due to the softness of the stone

Cost Of Marble

On average, marble costs anywhere from $60 to $100 per square foot. A 30-square-foot countertop would be anywhere from $1800 to $3000. If you were to take the same size countertop in granite, it would cost $1000 to $1500.

Marble Durability

Marble is calcite which is considered very porous and soft. Thus, staining, cracking, etching, and other issues are more likely to happen with a softer stone.

Maintenance For Marble Countertops

Installers will seal the marble upon installation to help homeowners protect their investment. However, you can expect to reseal the countertop every four to six months to keep it looking beautiful. The time frame will depend upon how often you use and clean the countertops in your kitchen.

Cleaning marble is very similar to granite because you need to use a PH-neutral cleaner to avoid damaging your marble countertop.

Choosing Granite Or Marble: A Personal Choice

Now that you better understand marble and granite kitchen countertops, it’s time to make your decision.

Regarding durability and maintenance, granite is the clear winner of this. After all, sealing once a year versus a few times per year is more manageable.

However, marble beats granite hands down regarding how smooth this feels once installed. So, how do you choose between two essentially evenly-matched options?

Ultimately, it comes down to what type of look you are going for with your Lancaster, PA, kitchen remodel. You want your kitchen countertop to match your cabinets and flooring. Thus, if you are only updating your countertops, you may have a smaller selection of what will work.

Also, consider your lifestyle when making your selection. Do you need more durability due to cooking frequently or having many people in and out of your kitchen?

The good news is that these stones will make for some fantastic countertops in your Lancaster, PA, kitchen! Either option will allow you to finally have the dream kitchen you have always wanted, complete with gorgeous countertops.

Free Consultations For Your Lancaster, PA Remodel

Whether you are looking for a partial or full kitchen remodel with new countertops for your Lancaster, PA kitchen – we are the professionals to call.

Here at MBC Remodeling, we offer free consultations to help you get your kitchen to the dream kitchen you have always wanted, including the perfect countertops.

Contact us today or call us at (717) 371-5136 to let us help you design your dream kitchen with countertops that will be gorgeous.

Share this article